What’s Wrong with IT Strategy?


Why does IT Strategy work sometimes and not others?


By definition, every organization has an IT Strategy - some are articulated, and others are working toward one without knowing it.

The question is: Is the IT Strategy producing results?

One can also ask the same question differently: What must one do to make IT Strategy produce results? Or, perhaps, what is wrong with this IT Strategy?

The strength of an IT Strategy does not come from it being articulated. It lies along its entire lifecycle - from the vision to the underlying policies, framework, and process design, including management and control mechanisms and execution. Each of them must be carefully thought through and designed.

Vision, principles, and policies set the direction for an IT Strategy. They are the first step to designing and defining an IT Strategy, but, more importantly, they reflect the stakeholders' beliefs. The strategy must evolve from these beliefs, otherwise, execution will be "half-hearted." It is also essential to realize that "stakeholders" include both the strategy's designers and executors.

A framework provides structure to IT Strategy. It enables rapid, repeatable results by ensuring we have a complete "picture" and make the critical connections. Frameworks might not guarantee success, but they help sustain and repeat it. Sometimes, they can also salvage a floundering effort by identifying the root cause of failure. Without a framework, success or failure is a black box. More often than not, success comes from tinkering with an initial failure. Frameworks are invaluable in this tinkering.

Sometimes we forget that IT Strategy is a process, not a point-in-time event. Like any other process, the IT Strategy must also be designed and have an "owner." It must also be integrated with other processes such as Budget, Portfolio Rationalization, Enterprise Architecture Planning, and Systems Implementation. It must also be monitored and controlled using clearly defined metrics and mechanisms.

Execution makes all the difference between the success and failure of an IT Strategy. An IT Strategy might look good on paper. However, implementation is where the rubber meets the road, and for the first time, we know for sure if things are working as planned. As much as strategy drives execution, the reverse is also equally true. A good IT Strategy is built factoring in "practical" considerations or execution "constraints." Also, on an ongoing basis, real data from execution must be used to "fine-tune" strategy.

For the sake of brevity, we cannot delve into all the issues affecting IT Strategy. So let us look at ten key reasons why IT Strategies fail to, well, sizzle:

Show me the alignment?

IT Strategy and alignment are such nebulous terms that most people have difficulty defining them in an actionable manner. It is OK to say that an IT Strategy will align IT with business, but it is another matter that most people cannot prove this alignment. Most CIOs cannot say if their IT is aligned with the business.

Show me the value?

Another concern is whether an IT Strategy will create verifiable and sustainable results. One of the reasons for business leaders' dissatisfaction with IT in general, and IT Strategy in particular, is that one cannot verify results. We know that IT Alignment creates shareholder value. However, if one cannot verify alignment itself, one cannot expect to be taken seriously when one claims that it resulted in shareholder value creation.

What is the ROI of NPV?

It is hard to argue with Peter Drucker when he says, "If you cannot measure it, you cannot manage it." However, is measurement is not restricted to financial measures such as NPV. It is not synonymous with "dollar-denominated."

IT is different. Its value cannot be measured only through NPV or other financial measures. Its measure does not have to be dollar-denominated. There are other, better means of measuring IT Value.

How does this decision impact IT Value?

An IT Strategy is not an end in itself. Organizations need to keep it updated. For example, unanticipated events require a response that might not have been considered in the original strategy. It is critical to understand how these decisions, in response to these events, affect the IT Strategy. Also, how do they impact value creation originally identified?

How does this business decision impact IT?

Stuff happens. In a business, it happens frequently and, more often than not, without warning. Speed and agility of response differentiate businesses that succeed. Quickly, one would like to know the impact of a business event on its IT. Also, how can IT help respond to them - efficiently and effectively?

IT Strategy framework must seamlessly traverse the business and IT boundaries to quickly assess the impact of an event across the entire organization. It should allow for quick decision-making in response to these events - by assessing the impact of each decision on shareholder value.

One big leap or baby steps?

Success, often, is a multi-step process, especially in uncharted territory. Our response to an initial stumble determines if it is a minor glitch or a decisive blow. A good framework, process with a feedback loop, and metrics help this endeavor.

IT Strategy's success is no different. Our first foray might result in some problems. We should be able to know when we have faltered, if it is a glitch or a blunder, and quickly assess the reason for our stumble. We must also be able to devise a response quickly.

Can I learn from my experience?

The classic definition of insanity is: repeating the same steps and expecting different results.

Why do IT organizations behave insanely? Because most organizations do not spend time analyzing, documenting, incorporating, disseminating, or teaching their "lessons learned." Best practices are not disseminated from one part of the organization to the other. Failures are hidden. New team members are not taught "what works" and "what doesn't." Processes are not modified to incorporate lessons learned.

Your "next" IT Strategy is bound to deliver the same results as this one - nothing less, nothing more.

Is this a steering committee or a team?

Often, IT Strategy is delegated to a steering committee comprised of participants from different functions. Each participant brings excellent, relevant, and complementary skills to the table.

However, this is a great idea that fails during execution.

A successful team must have clearly defined roles and responsibilities. Each team member must understand how the different pieces of the puzzle fit together. Each member must "deliver" something. Together, then, the team delivers results.

Steering committees result in the right people attending all the right meetings. However, they do not focus on role definition. They also fail to assign responsibility for deliverables. More often than not, these committees turn into debating societies where a lot of good stuff is discussed but very little, if anything, of value, is ever delivered.

Who will lose their job if this fails?

Accountability is critical to the success of an IT Strategy. One can create a very "good" IT Strategy that either stays on the shelf or fails miserably when executed. Such strategies and failures will continue until success or failure is linked to executive compensation and career.

Are we in compliance?

IT standards are a critical enabler of IT Strategy because they help lower the cost of operations. Organizations invest in standards teams that take great pains in defining standards. Often, the IT Strategy process is not linked to a compliance process. Hence, projects that do not adhere to technical standards get implemented. Thus a great IT Strategy results in a higher than-desirable cost of operations.

This is by no means an exhaustive list. However, addressing these will take us many steps closer to the solution.


Signup for Thought Leader

Get the latest IT management thought leadership delivered to your mailbox.

Mailchimp Signup (Short)

Join The Largest Global Network of CIOs!

Over 75,000 of your peers have begun their journey to CIO 3.0 Are you ready to start yours?
Mailchimp Signup (Short)