This first review or gate in the state gate review answers the question: How does this investment and its implementation program fit into our overall strategy? The response confirms that the program has merit in context, has been selected based upon thorough analysis and research, and is feasible i.e. can be implemented to achieve results.
The second review or gate evaluates the investment program's business case for compliance and feasibility – will it work? will it deliver promised results? – or in other words is this promise too good to be true? This review ensures key stakeholder support and buy-in to the program, tight coupling of the program and business objectives, and a thorough review of the cost, benefits and risks identified in the business case for accuracy, and completeness.
This third review or gate defines a clear plan for program implementation taking into account the vendor and supplier market and aligning it with project needs – are we ready for program implementation? are we ready for supplier/vendor participation? do we have a robust build or buy strategy and plan? At this review, an evaluation of assumptions and parameters of a business case is also revisited.
This fourth review or gate builds upon the build versus buy strategy by confirming that the project is still required, affordable and achievable, and making sure that before any work is awarded to an implementation partner that their selection is based upon a robust analysis – they are worthy and capable of delivering results before they are engaged.
This fifth review or gate assesses organizational readiness for change, confirms the proposed solution's applicability and robustness, operational budgets are in place, and a process to measure results after implementation.
This sixth review or gate confirms if the program is delivering promised benefits. This review is conducted post implementation or at specific decision points after implementation has commenced. It may be repeated after implementation is completed and throughout the service life of the implemented solution. Lessons learned are applied to future investments to further hone in successful policies, processes and practices.
This guide describes the key questions that must be answered to evaluate the implementation strategy for the program – does it make sense? is it realistic? are key stakeholders on board? is there a plan? how meaningful and realistic is it?
This guide describes the key questions that must be answered to evaluate the entire program – does the business case make sense to continue investment? is it realistic? are key stakeholders on board? is there an implementation plan? how meaningful and realistic is it?
This guide describes the key questions that must be answered to evaluate the organizational readiness for program implementation – will business operations work as planned? will benefits be realized as promised?
This guide describes the key questions that must be answered to evaluate the benefits realized from the program – business operations work as planned? benefits being realized as promised?